Art halps, plz?

[spazz]

I need your thoughts on why this doesn't look like Jared Padalecki, but instead a mutant-zombie creature with squinty eyes.




And for comparison:




Should I scrap it, or can it be saved? I've been staring at it for about a half hour now tweaking the eyes and they're just... so wonky. Plus the jaw needs serious work. Argh.

All thoughts are muchly appreciated!